Nook Impressions
Posted by Jim | Posted in Entertainment, Tech | Posted on 14-02-2010
0
So I bought my wife a Nook for Valentine’s Day. She still buys paper books and they’re stacking up all over the place. For someone who hates clutter, I figured having a single half inch thick device to hold her books might be appreciates. I think the jury may still be out on that.
Anyway, I myself own a Kindle2 and a Sony PRS-300 (Pocket Reader) having traded in my Sony PRS-500 late last year instead of upgrading it to support the new ePub format. So, as is probably obvious, I am an early adopter of eReaders as well as a proponent. The Kindle2 and PRS-300 each have their pros and cons for buying and reading ebooks, but I’m not going to be going into those here.
I do want to provide my early thoughts on the Nook, though, after having set it up for my wife. The very first impression was that it was quite difficult to get it out of its packing.
Once that was accomplished, though, the big thing I noticed was the color screen. There is an interaction between the e-Ink and color screens that takes a little getting used. Also, the soft keyboard on the color screen has smallish keys, though being an iPhone user it wasn’t too much of a stretch. The biggest impression was twofold: 1 – It feels a little sluggish. Performance could be better. 2. It’s HEAVY. The Kindle2 and PRS-300 are both very light devices, but the Nook has considerably more heft. It probably weighs similar to a decent-sized hardcover book.
We haven’t purchased any books on it yet. I expect that the experience should actually be better than Kindle2 due to the color screen. The Sony purchase experience is only thru the PC software since it has no wifi or wireless radio, so it will clearly be better than that.
UPDATE @ 8:39pm
Purchased first book on Nook. “Food Rules” by Michael Pollan, in case you were curious. Again, performance issues continue to mar the overall user experience. The nook feels like it should be snappier, probably because most color screen UI’s are snappier. I am accustomed to slowish refresh rates on the e-Ink displays, but I expect that hi rez color displays are snappy. The fact that the book buying experience is a mesh of the two probably contributes to the overall feeling of sluggishness. However, once I found a book I wanted to buy, the purchase experience was pain free and simple. I think if B&N improves the firmware to the point where the color UX feels snappy, the whole thing will come together more.
Now, I need to stop using my wife’s Valentine’s Day present.

